All Books/Class 5/EVS/Chapter 18

Chapter 18: No Place for Us?

EVS • Class 5

Download PDF

Loading PDF...

Chapter Analysis

Beginner9 pages • English

Quick Summary

The chapter 'No Place for Us?' revolves around Jatrya and his family, who are forced to leave their village due to the construction of a big dam. The narrative describes their move from a serene, community-based rural life to the challenges of urban living in Sinduri and then to Mumbai. It highlights the tribulations of displacement, adaptation to new environments, and the quest for a better future amid hardships. The story also touches upon the emotional and cultural adjustments the family has to undergo while seeking acceptance in a large city.

Key Topics

  • Displacement due to infrastructure projects
  • Challenges of urban migration
  • Economic hardships of displaced families
  • Cultural and emotional challenges
  • Community support and integration
  • The concept of home and belonging
  • Adaptation to new environments

Learning Objectives

  • Understand the impact of displacement on families
  • Recognize the challenges faced during urban migration
  • Identify the economic and social difficulties in urban environments
  • Discuss the importance of community support for displaced families
  • Reflect on the cultural and emotional adaptation required when moving to a new place

Questions in Chapter

What had Jatryabhai thought while moving to Mumbai? Did he find Mumbai as he had imagined?

Page 173

What kind of school do you think Jatrya’s children would be going to in Mumbai?

Page 173

Do you think their life may be better in a big city from what it was before?

Page 173

Do you know of any family that has come to your town after having moved out of their place?

Page 173

Additional Practice Questions

Discuss how displacement affects families emotionally and economically.

medium

Answer: Displacement often leads to emotional distress due to separation from a familiar environment and community. Economically, it can cause a loss of livelihood and increased financial burden due to the costs of relocation and adaptation to new areas.

What are possible solutions to help families displaced by large infrastructure projects?

hard

Answer: Solutions include adequate compensation, providing employment opportunities, access to education, and creating communities that embrace displaced families, ensuring they become integrated into the new social fabric.

Why do you think it's important to address language barriers for displaced families?

medium

Answer: Addressing language barriers is crucial for better integration into new communities, as it facilitates communication, access to services, employment, and overall community participation for displaced families.

Imagine and describe a day in the life of Jatrya’s family in Mumbai.

easy

Answer: A typical day could involve the adults working long hours in informal jobs, while the children balance school and part-time work. They face challenges like crowded living conditions, high costs of living, and the emotional stress of adapting to urban life.

Analyze the role of the community in helping displaced families like Jatrya’s.

medium

Answer: Communities play a vital role in providing social support, sharing resources, and creating a welcoming environment that allows displaced families to integrate better and rebuild their lives.